Strengthening Constitutional Self-Government

No Left Turns

Consequences of campaign finance reforms

Here are a couple of ordinary reports on the meaning and/or consequences of the Court’s decision to uphold the campaign finance laws. This is merely a start. Tom Edsall of the WaPo, explaining who the winners and losers are. Sensible, as far as it goes, as long as it is understood that in the long run it is the two party system that is the loser. Glenn Justice of the NY Times takes on the issue in much the same way as Edsall does. McConnell’s right: "Soft money is not gone, it has just changed its address." New organizations, special interests, fund-raisers, rich guys who want more direct influence, third parties, will all benefit. People like George Soros will end benefitting most. It is certain that at least the Democratic Party (and eventually perhaps even the GOP) will be greatly disadvantaged; it will turn into a small mom-and pop operation, with Mr. and Mrs. Smith’s small annual contributions not being able to compete with the likes of Soros who will give to other newly created organizations that will prove to be more ideological and narrow, and, unfortunately, will have a tremendous effect on the tone and quality of public deliberations. None of this will be to the benfit of the country in the long run. It’s a shame. By the way, there is an argument brewing on whether or not this decision is the longest Court decision ever--that may be reserved to Dred Scott--but it is probable that it’s consequences will be on par with that other infamous case, regardless of length.

Discussions - 1 Comment

This might be considered Dred III (I consider Lawrence v Texas to be Dred II. Can the Republic long endure these affronts to...?

I tend to agree with Limbaugh’s take today: this wasn’t so much the Courts doing as it was Bush and the Republicans. Though a majority of House GOPs voted against it (to their great credit), just not enough to keep it from the Senate. Of course this dreadful deal won’t keep the president up at nights, the Republicans will be sittin’ pretty for the time being.

Down the road, this baby is gonna be overturned or will wreck havoc on the, as you say, two party system, the very source of our strength, and protection of our country against the forces of tyranny.

Leave a Comment

* denotes a required field
 

No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: http://nlt.ashbrook.org/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/3238