Posted by Joseph Knippenberg
This article (which I havent yet had a chance to read)--summarized here--argues for a drift toward the center in some academic disciplines, albeit not in the humanities.
Yea, lets get out our microscopes!
Dan Kleins comments in the InsideHigherEd article are right on. It doesnt make much sense to ask how faculty identify themselves. Just as everyone in the U.S. tends to believe they are middle class, most tend to view themselves as moderates. Asking them where they stand on specific issues will yield far clearer results.
Second for Johns point. And lots of academics live in academic communities and have a circle of friends limited to academics. Whats a moderate in that world?
Another thing to keep in mind is the drift of the disciplines. If a prof is assigning reading that reflects whats new and "important" in the field, you know what that would mean in history, sociology, English, etc.
Louie makes a good point about the constraints of particular disciplines. In political science, I think it is possible to provide balance and moderation. For one thing, we are supposed to encourage students to think poltically, and that requires real effort on the students parts. Instructors who think of teaching as indoctrination simply arent taken seriously by the students, who have learned discounting to get a grade. For what its worth, I tell undergraduates that if I succeed in the course, they will not be able to tell what my politics are, but that I will tell them on the last day if they ask.
And what exactly do you tell them, if they ask (on the last day)?
dain - The truth, of course.
dain - This isnt what the thread was about. . .but I tell them that I have been a Democrat all my life; that I come from a long line of progressive Republicans, who enthusiastically embraced Ike; that I am a democrat, a moderate, occasionally a ticket splitter, especially on foreign policy; on educational/pedagogical matters, a conservative of sorts. I hate everything that TV has done (though I will watch sports in a pub), but I love satellite radio; my wife and I belong to a fantasy football league (shes the expert), and we love womens college basketball. We are a politically mixed couple - and our mutts are therefore named Chester A. Arthur and Louis McHenry Howe. My complex religious views, such as they are, are none of your business. Let us pray that this is enough for you.
Well, I wasnt asking for your bio, dude. And a simple "I prefer not to say" would have sufficed if you found the question irritating. I wont bore you with why I was curious.
Ashbrook Center at Ashland University | 401 College Avenue | Ashland, Ohio 44805 | (419) 289-5411 | (877) 289-5411 (Toll Free)