Strengthening Constitutional Self-Government

No Left Turns

A note an education

David Brooks’ brief op-ed tells a good story. It is about the value of a non-specialized education, perhaps even a liberal education. It is about the relationship between theory and practice, about big ideas and big events. Maybe it’s about the how a young person sees the old, and vica versa. It is about judgments, the word that most people in the academy want to avoid like the plague. No, it is really more about learning. Actually, it is about what it is to be a student and how it is that universities should not encourage "squirrel-like specialization." In the end, it is about what a student should be and what a teacher should be. Brooks leads me to a short thought (I know, you’re surprised).

When Freshmen enter my Understanding Politics class they always look for the wrong things. They look for the narrow and the limited. They think we are going to talk about who gets what and how, which group wants a revolution, or how a bill becomes a law, which special interest has the most influence and why. Then they note in order to understand the daily headlines, the first thing we read is Xenophon’s Education of Cyrus, and we do so not because we are interested in Persian history. Xenophon’s first paragraph goes something like this: Isn’t it interesting how many democracies have been brought down "by those who wished the governing to be done in some other way than under a democracy." And he mentions monarchies and oligarchies and tyrannies. He also notes that cattlemen and horsemen are the rulers of cattles and horses, and those animals are more willing to obey their rulers than are men. Men are hard to rule, maybe even impossible to rule: "human beings unite against none more than against those whom they perceive attempting to rule them."
And then Xenophon says that because there was Cyrus who acquired "very many people, very many cities, and very many nations, all obedient to himself" in may be possible to say that ruling human beings is not impossible, or even difficult, "if one does it with knowledge." Well, we talk about these things for a while (about four years) and we read all the others who have addresseed the issue--Aristotle, Locke, Madison and the boys, Shakespeare, Churchill, Lincoln--and then the students become citizens and are ruled and rule in turn. No squirrel-like specialization here.
This education is partly private, but mostly common because this regime is attached to freedom, and freedom is the easiest things to misunderstand; it is easy to think that freedom is doing whatever one wants, and it is easy to fall into the habit of wanting to change the democratic regime that allows freedom into something else. Freedom can be self-destructive. To encourage that understanding of freedom would be to corrupt the young. Men are no harder to rule than they are to educate.

Discussions - 8 Comments

Any suggestions/links to a reading list that would be suitable to educate those of us who came late to an interest in politics and suffered under unduly narrow college curriculi?

I’m looking to re-educate myself. Thanks!

May I suggest everything written by N. Machiavelli?

You can pick up books by Susan Wise Bauer on the "classical education you never had." I might also suggest picking up "From Dawn to Decadence," by Jacques Barzun, are reading books on the myriad of topics written on since the Renaissance. Other than that, start with Homer, Shakespeare, Plutarch, Plato, Socrates, Thucydides, Aristotle, and work your way forward. Sound like enough of a task? Oh, and read the Claremont Review, and read books referred to throughout the book reviews and articles.

You would have to throw in "THe Closing of the American Mind," as a primer, of course.

Christopher Lach, John Ralston Saul... what a list it could be...


The Closing of the American Mind as a PRIMER?

Come on. A provocative text for Straussians and those who study them, yes. An interesting (largely unread) bestseller to be sure. But a primer to a classically liberal education?

No. I don’t think we should recommend it as that. Some of Strauss’s essays would be a better start, but still probably verge beyond "primer" status.

In regards to Barzun, I’d recommend The House Of Intellect. Some obvious questions come to mind: 1) how do you define a liberal education, 2) what are the goals you want to achieve with your students, 3) how best to achieve those goals.
And also -where do the sciences fit in? Or do they?

If people truly want a liberal (non-specialized) education in which they will learn to think, they should investigate St. John’s College, either its BA program or its MA program -- at either of its two campuses: Annapolis, MD, or Santa Fe, NM. One can also acquire much of this particular type of education in two other ways. Training teachers in using the Great Books Program ( enables those teachers (in public and private schools for all age levels) to learn to teach so that students develop THINKING skills.

An education is amongst the most valuable of things to have, and once you have a bachelor's degree, it all but guarantees you extra money in your career. However, the question is worthy as to whether going to an elite, private college is worth the cost of education. According to a report by Smart Money, the answer is a resounding no. Private college graduates had a lower amount of return on their cost of attendance and degree versus career earnings and extra money than graduates of state schools. The most elite of elites, the Ivy League schools, amongst the world's most prestigious, had the worst rate of returns. Here are the results of the SmartMoney study and more ideas on how to save extra money on college.

Leave a Comment

* denotes a required field

No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL:

Warning: include(/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2004/07/a-note-an-education.php on line 608

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/opt/sp/php7.2/lib/php') in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2004/07/a-note-an-education.php on line 608