Disregarding for the moment the fact that Michael McConnell is both an evangelical and an intellectual, this line of argument is not uninteresting. I will say that if the Bush Administration is going to mobilize evangelicals on Mierss behalf, they havent yet succeeded in doing so, at least down in the grass roots. My church friends (generally well-informed and generally well-educated) havent yet focused on the Miers nomination, and dont go googoo-eyed when they hear that shes an evangelical. Just an anecdote, I know....
Score one for the evangelicals, then. Some of them are seeing through the smokescreen.