Strengthening Constitutional Self-Government

No Left Turns

That’s Why They Play the Game

Happy New Year, for those of you bleary-eyed from watching the conclusion of the NFL regular season and the holiday bowl games. You may have other reasons for being hung over, but I pass these by.

Joe Pa, sitting with his injured leg in the press box, beat Phillip Fullmer in whatever brand-name bowl game Penn State played. Good. Michigan now will, or should, stop complaining about being left out of the BCS championship game. Before the Rose Bowl there was already a constituency arguing that Michigan should be named co-national champions (being so voted in the presumptive final AP poll), following the inevitable dismantling of USC and perhaps a lucky, tainted Florida victory over Ohio State. Could there be any other kind? Instead we had a game that brought back memories of the old Pac-10 dominance of the Rose Bowl. The real #2 team in the country – if not Florida – seems to be USC. Or Boise State. About which more later.

But perhaps we shouldn’t be too hard on Michigan fans or draw cosmic conclusions from the Rose Bowl, especially in terms of Ohio State’s chances against Florida. The time lag between the last game of the regular season and the January bowls is so long that teams seldom perform as they would had that game had been played much closer to the event – as in a playoff system. USC evidently recovered from a very bad loss to UCLA better than Michigan did from a much more explicable loss to Ohio State. Even then the Rose Bowl was tied at halftime. But the system is what it is, so all credit to Pete Carroll. And a memo to NFL personnel directors: if you draft USC wide receiver Dwayne Jarrett and are surprised to find yourself with a T.O or Randy Moss situation on your hands, you have no one to blame but yourself.

Now about Boise State’s victory over Oklahoma, the insane post-midnight ending of which those of you in the eastern and central time zones may have missed (don’t get me started on TV scheduling and the timing rules in college football). Full disclosure: yes, I am a native of Idaho.

Yes, it was an absolute classic. Hollywood would have rejected the script of the game as completely improbable. It included three trick plays, including the old backyard favorite, the Statue of Liberty, that turned the tide after all seemed lost. The star running back proposed marriage to his girlfriend/cheerleader on national TV, a few minutes after he scored the winning two-point conversion. The critical moments will be replayed for years to come, like Vince Young’s TD run in last year’s Rose Bowl – or, even more apt, “the band is out on the field” conclusion to the Stanford-Cal game. It was a reminder why college sports are worth watching despite all the problems. It is why they play the game. If they show it on ESPN Classic, tape it and watch it.

BSU’s win was not quite as stunning as the original “Rocky,” or Hickory High School (in real life, Milan High School) of “Hoosiers” fame, or even George Mason during the 2006 NCAA basketball tournament. (George Mason, by the way, took out a full page add in the Boise newspaper before the game, offering support from one Cinderella to another.) The school is perhaps best known nationally for its silly blue playing field in Boise – but the win was no fluke. Boise State has a distinguished football tradition. That matters in sports. As a junior college it won the old JC Rose Bowl. It won a NCAA Division I-AA championship. Over the last few years, BSU has been ranked consistently in the NCAA D-I Top 25 and finished #7 in 2004.

And no, the team is not composed of innocent raw young men who are persuaded to leave the potato fields and who are astonished to see the big city. There are a fair number of players from Idaho – which is increasingly urbanized and has produced NFL players like Jerry Kramer and Jake Plummer. But the largest contingent comes from the high school football factories in California. BSU for years has successfully recruited those Californians, such as running back Ian Johnson, who don’t quite make the cut to USC. But they are pretty darned good nonetheless, and they have a bit of a chip on their shoulder. First-year coach Chris Peterson was the offensive mastermind behind BSU’s success over the past few seasons and his innovation and play-calling courage (after being somewhat too conservative in the second half) was inspired. BSU’s defense, especially against the run, was surprisingly stout and opportunistic until it wore down.

The real reason for college football fans to cheer Boise State’s win is that it helps open up the game. The schools from the six power conferences don’t want to see the Boise States’ of the world succeed, any more than they wanted George Mason to get on a run last spring. To be sure, if this particular Boise State team played in the Pac-10 or the Big-10 or the SEC, rather than the WAC, it almost certainly would not have been undefeated. It’s very hard to see the current Broncos winning two more games in a national championship playoff. But if Boise State or its non-BCS conference fellows had equal access to money, facilities, and TV exposure – who knows? As it is, the performance gap is not nearly as wide as most think. And there is the underdog factor. Far more Boise State fans made the trip than did Oklahoma supporters. Casual fans watching on TV instantly chose their allegiance. Bob Stoops of Oklahoma, no fool, knew all that coming into the game. He knew BSU was good. He probably wasn’t thrilled with a match up that he could not win, no matter the final score.

That’s why they play the game. And in spite of everything, why we watch. And why college football, including Big-10 football, would be even better if the competition base is expanded.

Discussions - 12 Comments

I’m not so sure that BSU couldn’t win another game in a playoff format. To be honest, they dominated the game until the fourth quarter, when their defense seemed to tire and were on the field for too long because of the conservative play-calling of Petersen.

But enough with speculation. I watched the game thinking that perhaps Oklahoma had left too much time on the clock when they converted the two point conversion to tie the game because BSU had two timeouts left. When Zabransky (BSU QB) threw that (unblievably poor choice of a throw) interception, all I could think of was what a bad way to end a great game. As it turned out, that was only the beginning.

The statute of liberty play was cool to see, but the gutsiest call was the hook and ladder. The reciever who caught the forward pass on the play showed unbelievalbe discipline for not turning and getting the first down, which he could have done with about 11 seconds still left on the clock and a timeout(the play was ran on 4th and 18, so a first down would have given them at least two more plays). And how about sending the QB in motion as the slot receiver and having a former walk-on WR throw a pass on 4th and 2 in order to score the TD in OT? Wild stuff.

First game I can remember where I wasn’t a fan of either team and I literally jumped off the couch with excitement; waking up my girlfriend, the dog, and my roommate in the process with my yells of disbelief. A great game.

Too long a post. This is a political site.

If Ohio State wins, it hard to see how Boise State doesn’t end up #2. Wisconsin was not impressive in its bowl, and everyone else would have 2 losses.

If Ohio State wins, it hard to see how Boise State doesn’t end up #2. Wisconsin was not impressive in its bowl, and everyone else would have 2 losses.

I agree. But you know what? Being #2 used to matter, but it doesn’t any more. It’s all about #1 ... the rest of the runners-up are just "not #1." Yeah, it’ll help recruiting and such to have done well, but #2 vs. #5 doesn’t matter.

As a side note, Michigan was pitiful. And I could not believe a USC player was boastfully saying "We should have a shot at OSU!" You lost two games in the regular season ... you deserve nothing.

I agree on the Dwayne Jarrett comment - he deserved two unsportsmanlike conduct calls (one for taunting a guy as he went into the end zone and another for the faux-jump shot after a TD).

Good win for BSU, and a heck of a game.

To True Right: Your understanding of politics is too narrow. Sports has to do with politics because it has to do with human excellence and it has to do with rewards, mostly public. Some it has to do with heroism, most of it with honor. One Greek named Kallikrates, according to the monument erected by his fellow atheletes, "has obtained with sweat and toil a glorious reputation." The inscription ends: "He took care of his soul."

Sorry to disagree, I’m a big Gators fan. I think BSU is great but they won’t ever settle the question about whether they belong or not until they really step up-I suggest they apply to be part of the Big 10, Pac 10 or Big 12, and start winning their conference outright. That will put an end to it once and for all.

I happened to be playing No-Limit Holdem in Lawton Oklahoma during the game. The whole game a lone Boise State fan had been infuriating the growing crowd who was watching the game on the big screens at the bar behind the poker room. Turns out the Boise State fan had bet on Boise but had only received 6 points, while all the OU fans who had taken OU had given up 8(those Bookies are way too clever!) any case he was rather furious when OU took the lead on the interception, and he took a lot of heat from the semi-drunken crowd. Because of his focus on the game I was able to steal a nice pot from him at around this time. When Boise made a miracle play he was jumping up and down in delight, at which point several OU fans complained and wished him ejected from the Casino on the grounds that he was povoking a fight. Until the poker players interceded on his behalf, security was considering ejecting him! Realizing that the poker game had become great due to the great football being played...I did my best to ignore it and prey upon those who had lost focus. When I realized that this was impossible I cashed out and watched the remainder of the game with full focus. The Boise state "fan" made peace with some of the OU crowd by cheering for Boise to miss the two-point conversion(since he had already made his spread) but it was a little too late as three drunken OU fans challenged him to a brawl outside at the conclusion of the game...thankfully security came in and ejected the drunkards. Moral of the story: Don’t cheer for the underdog when outnumbered 500 to 1, and secondly sometimes a great football game will absorb you regardless of your best intentions. The game was incredible!

Jerry Kramer! Next thing you know, you’ll be invoking Harmon Killebrew.

I just wish Boise State would stop beating Fresno State.

Two things.

First, I think the blue field is great. It’s distinctive and is a clear sign that you are on their turf. It’s tradition, uniqueness and - yes - goofiness is part of what makes college ball fun.

I agree. But you know what? Being #2 used to matter, but it doesn’t any more. It’s all about #1 ... the rest of the runners-up are just "not #1." Yeah, it’ll help recruiting and such to have done well, but #2 vs. #5 doesn’t matter.

It matters if you’re BSU, but not if you’re OSU.

It does seem to me too that being no. 2 would be a big deal in Boise. After all, George Mason, in truth, didn’t get anywhere near the national championship.

Leave a Comment

* denotes a required field

No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL:

Warning: include(/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2007/01/thats-why-they-play-the-game.php on line 726

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/opt/sp/php7.2/lib/php') in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2007/01/thats-why-they-play-the-game.php on line 726