Strengthening Constitutional Self-Government

No Left Turns

California homeschooling follow-up

All the major homeschooling organizations in California are concerned. The case, which I discussed at length here, seems to have taken them by surprise. HSLDA had this to say:

The opinion holds that homeschooling is not a legal option in California. HSLDA strongly disputes this interpretation of California law. We believe that the court made a mistake when it relied on two decisions reached in the 1950s in order to show that homeschooling is not a legal option.


If the opinion is followed, then California will have the most regressive law in the nation and homeschooling will be effectively banned, because the only legal way to homeschool will be for the parent to hold a teaching certificate.

The court may well be right about the letter of the law, but the administrative interpretation of the law has clearly been more permissive. Whether it will continue to be so is an open question. At the moment, this decision applies only to these particular children; anyone who wants to pull other kids out of a homeschool setting and commit, er, place them in a more formal educational setting would have to seek a court order, citing this decision as a precedent. The state education bureaucracy is under no obligation to prefer the court’s reading of the law’s requirements to its own, though I suppose that it’s possible that they could use this as an excuse to crack down on homeschooling. The state legislature could also weigh in, indicating its preference as to how the law should be understood and administered.

If I had to bet, it would be that the bureaucrats and legislators will, all things being equal, let sleeping dogs lie. The common practice of declaring your home a private school will continue, as will the less common practice of following an independent study program affiliated with an umbrella school or organization.

Discussions - 3 Comments

All of this should not be surprising. Any Californians here? What on earth would keep you in that God forsaken place?

My ailing parents and in-laws who will not move - other than that I as a Native Bay Area California would leave at the drop of a hat. My child is homeschooled because the California public school system is in shambles and I don't want my child to become an experiment of a failed socialized school system.

The Pacific Justice Institute has announced that it is representing the Sunland Christian School in an appeal of this ruling to the California Supreme Court.

My family is in California because of my husband's job, which he loves. If we wanted to move to another state, he'd probably have to change industries & with a possible recession it's really not a great time to be doing that :-(

Leave a Comment

* denotes a required field
 

No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: http://nlt.ashbrook.org/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/12047