Strengthening Constitutional Self-Government

No Left Turns

Excerpts from Obama’s Notre Dame Address

Excerpts from an advance draft of Obama’s Notre Dame remarks:

This day reminds us about the basic meaning of Catholic.E Catholic with a small cEmeans broad, inclusive, universal. So it means above all generosity of spirit, warmth, and welcome. And that’s what you stand for. You are more catholic now than ever.

We see it in your campus. Notre Dame now contains women as well as men. People of all faiths, whose ancestors came from all over the world. This is the sort of campus where my mother and father could have met, romanced and married.

Notre Dame today is not exactly what we saw in that wonderful old movie, Knute Rockne: All American. We see in that classic film Notre Dame’s struggle for equal recognition with other schools. It is a moving story about Catholics becoming equal in an unequal society. It is an immigrant’s storyE

When I was in high school, the football teams I would root for would be the ones with black quarterbacks. One of the charms of the Knute Rockne movie for me was the black quarterback in Knute’s first sandlot scrimmage.

Nation-wide, all of this diversity leads up to this amazing situation: a black guy with a name weirder than Knute Rockne gets elected President. This is the only country in the world where this could happen. And it happened because, with all our wonderful diversity, we share a common faithE

America is more than having common enemies. As Lincoln implored the South, in his First Inaugural: “We must not be enemies, we must be friends.E Yet it is not enough for Americans to cease hating each other or even just competing with each otherE

What is at the heart of Catholic higher education, what is at the heart of America, is the chance to be better Americans in a more generous America. A black kid has no need to look for the team with the black quarterbackE

We can agree on this, even as some of us obviously don’t agree on others. We differ in our religious convictions, for example. You might be cradle Catholics; I came to my faith fairly late in my life. Yet we have had presidents of all sorts of religious convictions and they have managed to be presidents of all the people. What we can all have in common is something people of all faiths and even those without faith can share in, and that is hopeE

I was raised by a mother in a family that was not in any conventional sense religious. But they were all deeply spiritual people.

When I was conceived, my father and mother were not married. As you may know, he was a graduate student from Kenya, she an undergraduate of 17. They were not religious people, in any ordinary sense. In such instances abortion would be advised and taken as the easy choice. You might even know of people who faced such circumstances.

So I am thankful, and I have prayed every day of my life, once I learned the power of prayer, that my mother did not take the easy choice. She had the right to abort me, but, thank God, she did not exercise it. Because she had hope. She did not make her choice out of religious conviction but because she had hope.

And isn’t that the meaning of your school motto: Vita, Dulcedo, Spes; Life, Sweetness, Hope.

That’s how she lived her all too brief life: with sweetness and hope, and she gave to her son the audacity to hope great things for my life. She inspires me still to live my life in the hope of bringing sweetness to many others, for whom life has lost savorE

As Pope Benedict the 16th said in his encyclical on Hope: “In hope we were saved, says Saint Paul to the Romans, and likewise to usE Redemption is offered to us in the sense that we have been given hope, trustworthy hope, by virtue of which we can face our present”….

Faith, hope, and love—these are the values we live by, the values that make us live and sacrifice. They make us strive beyond mere lifeE

You know well this date: November 26, 1842. In that same month and year that Fr. Sorin founded Notre Dame, Abe Lincoln married his wife.

Think about the hopes that young couple must have had. (The more I read about that marriage, the more I’m glad I’m married to Michelle.) Consider all the good Lincoln did this nation. It would not have been possible without that hope.

Abraham Lincoln gave hope for a new birth of freedom that brought us out of the Civil WarE

Confronted by the challenge of the Depression, Franklin Roosevelt gave hope to a demoralized nationE

Confronted by malaise and drift, the Gipper, Ronald Reagan, gave hope to a nation buffeted by domestic and foreign perils.

So let us give our future mothers, fathers, citizens, and people of the world hope that their lives will be sweet ones. Hope in the goodness of life. Hope that His justice and mercy will prevail, the whole wide world aroundE

Discussions - 9 Comments

What was the sin of Judas, and many another like him? It was to project on to the Messiah their own political agenda. What was that agenda? Israel was to be raised "uber alles," "over all." This grandiose vision of Israel in history was not to be questioned, not even by the Son of the Almighty. Because he challeneged it, because he came in a way wholly unacceptable to the Jewish establishment, the Son of David, the Son of God, would be nailed like a thing to a cross.

Now before us stands a political figure, who would dare presume to seize the message of "hope" of the Son of God himself, and take that and so debase it as to make it serve his own personal political agenda, and that of a corrupt Chicago political machine.

And he did this thing, this miserable thing, at a "university" named after the Theotokos, the Mother of God herself.

Why on earth should we thank God that someone did not exercise their rights? The backwardness of President Obama's logic boggles the mind.

So anyone who adopts a message of 'hope' is daring to 'seize the message' of the son of God himself? Perhaps Reagan was doing the same when he called America the 'last best hope' or William Bennet titled one of his books by that phrase? Dan your post was more messianic than anything Obama had to say.

What was he going to do? Get up to the mike and start talking about how great abortions are and the church is an antiquated bane on civilization? I find it more interesting that Allan Keyes was arrested for protesting during the whole dog and pony show.

While I'm thinking of it, ren: do you believe in free speech? I already know the right does not so please don't answer in the form of free speech zones in crawford Texas. Not really trying to be cute or combative I just really want to know what someone from the left thinks on the issue.

"She had the right to abort me, but, thank God, she did not exercise it. Because she had hope." I agree with Andrew. Obama pays lip service to the Founders' belief in rights, but something he calls "hope" trumps all. Does he think Lincoln's "hope" that black slaves would become free is what turned him into the Great Emancipator, rather than Lincoln's fundamental belief in the natural rights of every human being? Simply astounding that the president of the United States does not believe that as a human being in the womb, he did not have the right to live. Instead, his life was at the mercy of his mother's prerogative.

Ren, you're aware of the sharp distinction between embracing a message of hope, and deliberately wrapping yourself and your message of hope in the garments of a Messiah. Obama doesn't merely offer hope per se, he promises an earthly salvation that can be gained via political activity, and has deliberately cultivated an iconic status that has lent itself to a cult-like following that's entirely unhealthy in any functioning democracy.

Theologically, his words and actions are a sophistry. Politically, his words and actions are beyond unsettling, but positively unhealthy. And from a vantage point of Christianity, his actions are reprenhensible.

And Ren, there's nothing wrong with making some observations that tend towards the messianic when you're speaking of Notre Dame, for it's an institution named after the Messiah himself. I could have noted the dramatic chasm between Obama's use of biblical language and that of our founders, or our great political figures. But that's a "been there, done that."

My mistake for commenting on a speech NOT delivered. Fool me once, . . .

Leave a Comment

* denotes a required field

No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL:

Warning: include(/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2009/05/excerpts-from-obamas-notre-dame-address.php on line 665

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/sd/nlt-blog/_includes/promo-main.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/opt/sp/php7.2/lib/php') in /srv/users/prod-php-nltashbrook/apps/prod-php-nltashbrook/public/2009/05/excerpts-from-obamas-notre-dame-address.php on line 665